This review is for the medium sized version of the Commute 2012 (Amazon sometimes combines reviews)
This bag is the updated version of my first Timbuk2 bag, the Timbuk2 Commute 2.0 Laptop Messenger Bag and is intended to replace the older version. Building on the older version, Timbuk2 made a few refinements that would cause many to prefer this version over the older one.
As a part-time professional photographer, I wanted to carry my camera and a few lenses and flash (Nikon D300s, Nikon 17-35, Nikon 50mm, and Nikon SB-700) back and forth to my main job (office environment). I also needed to be able to carry associated work items such as files, pens, notepads, lunch, etc.... And, I wanted to be able to completely convert the bag between full photo use and straight up work and work travel use (more on that later). This bag, like the older version, is simply incredible in every regard. For perspective, I have owned bags from Lowe, Domke, Tenba, Crumpler, Swiss Gear, Think Tank, and nearly every other manufacturer, particularly those that make bags for photographers.
Every aspect of this bag, like its predecessor, exudes quality. Construction, durability, materials, all indicate this bag will last for many years even if abused. The zippers are among the highest quality I have used. The medium size of the bag was a perfect choice for me (I received it in Blackif that matters). Timbuk 2 bags seem to run larger and can be confusing at times. This bag is bigger than my previously owned Tenba Messenger Photo/Laptop Bag Small (Olive), which is actually the medium in the Tenba line (they have weird sizing as well). There is an abundance of organizational pockets, interior compartments, softpadded laptop compartment to fit a 14" (projected). I love having the large main compartment. The bottom outside of the bag is rubber coated and the swivel strap joints limit twisting of the strap. The area under the mainflap has a lot of storage/compartment space but for some reason, there are no quick access pockets on the exterior. When fully loaded, weight distribution is perfect and the carrying handle makes a world of difference for short jaunts. I did purchase the Timbuk2 Phoney Strap Pad (I believe it should have been included) to replace the OEM padded strap that came with the bag. In my opinion, it distributes the weight better while providing a place for my Iphone as well as a reflective surface. This bag could easily be used to pack everything for a 3 day weekend.
The newer version incorporates a Napoleon pocket with a zipper. Believe it or not, this feature adds a great deal of functionality to the bag and I sorely missed it on the older version. You can use it to store keys or items you may need to access while on the go, all without opening the bag flap. The newer version also modifies two pockets on the front of the bag (under the flap) with a special soft lining (very soft) that will hold any smartphone device and protect the screen. The inside of the bag also includes a pocket on each side that can hold a water bottle, or loose items, a feature I wish had bene included in the previous version that adds even greater organization.
USE AS A PHOTO GEAR BAG
Now, onto the photography aspect. By itself, the bag probably could be used for photo gear without an insert just as any other bag could. However, for adequate protection, you really need an insert. Thats where the Timbuk2 Snoop Camera Insert comes in. This is a removable insert that is self contained and is one of the better inserts I have used. Amazingly, it puts most Domke inserts to shame such as Domke Domke 720-250D Digital SLR Camera Insert (Green) and Domke 720-230 FA-230 3 Compartment Insert (Green). The Snoop Camera insert is made of very high quality materials, well structured, well padded, compact, has a handle, and can be zipped closed. The internal compartments are completely customizable and will fit a full size DSLR with a battery pack (rare for a messenger bag), 3 FX large lenses, an SB-700 (or 900), and a bunch of other gear such as remote cord, memory card wallet, spare batteries, etc... Even loaded, the bag is not that bulky (unlike my Tenba). The insert fits perfectly in the medium size Timbuk2 Commute 2.0 and you can still easily fit files or magazines around the bag or behind it. When I get to work and I need to carry mostly work stuff, I simply take out the insert, put it in my large desk drawer and go to meetings or whatever. If I want to travel for the weekend, I can leave the insert behind and just load the bag with travel gear (of course, I then need to carry a separate camera bag). Perfect Solution all around in my opinion.
This bag could easily be used for street photography. However, I still prefer my venerable Domke 700-02A F-2 Bag (Brown Waxwear Finish) for street shooting. This choice is more a matter of pure taste and not functionality (there us no direct camera access on the flap of either bag) and the Domke has less organization. Maybe I think I look like Nick Nolte in Under Fire [VHS].
Either waythis bag is pure winner, and even better than the older version (which was incredible).
As usual, I will edit review if anything changes.
I was absolutely positive this small-sized Timbuk2 case wouldn't hold my 15 inch MacBook Pro. The measurements on the page indicated that I had an eighth of an inch width to spare but that the computer was several eighths too tall. I was hoping that I'd at least be able to squeeze the computer inside.
My fears were laid to rest the moment the bag arrived. It's an excellent fit, neither loose nor tight, but just right, and the velcro strap that holds the computer firmly in its sleeve is adjustable and forgiving of my slightly tall computer. Most importantly, the case zippers up over the sleeve containing the computer without any problem or hesitation. I would guess most 15" PCs will easily fit this small (but quite large) bag, though you would definitely need the medium bag for a 17" laptop.
Of course, you could always put your larger computer in the main part of the bag, but the beauty of the sleeve is that the bag zips open to lie flat so you don't have to get your computer out in the airport security line. While I only fly a couple times a year, that perk alone is worth its weight in gold.
The rest of the bag is as well-constructed and luxurious as the company claims. There are padded compartments to slip an iPad or notebook in, which work great for cameras, camcorders and other electronics, or old-fashioned paper books. I especially like the flat divided pocket directly under the front flap because I can keep my phone or digital recorder and a compact camera in easy reach. (And while the reaching is easy, you're in no danger of losing anything because the big openings have both clasps and Velcro fasteners, while interior pockets are equipped with Velcro.) There's also a very room flat holder for pens and other office supplies and a net bag built into the interior side that can be used for most anything. I'm thinking I'll pop an apple into it more often than not.
There's a huge amount of room in the main compartment. I'm using this messenger bag in a few days when I fly as my carryon and have no doubt I can easily fit a change of clothes and important toiletries in it as well as the computer, cameras, notepads and books I'll be needing. Not only that, this will slide under the seat I don't like putting things in the overhead compartment.
On the outside, this is a beautiful, sleek bag with a pocket on one side to hold a bottle of water. There is a luggage pass-through so you don't have to carry it while pulling along a suitcase, but if you do, the removable, easy-to-adjust shoulder strap has a removable padded sleeve to save your shoulder. Without the strap, there's a built-in handle so you can carry it like a briefcase. It's comfortable as well.
From the fasteners that make snapping the shoulder strap off and on easier than I thought possible, to the feel of the zippers and the padded interiors, this bag is both elegant and imminently utilitarian. The company guarantees it and I can see why: I expect to use this bag daily for many years. It's absolutely the best I've ever had.
Buy Timbuk2 Commute TSA-Friendly Messenger Bag Now
All I can say about the Timbuk2 Commute 2012 Messenger Bag is ......wow! OK, I can say a bit more:
This bag is fairly lightweight, yet very strong. I just took it on a trip and I packed it full of things, yet due to its design it still remained TSA compliant so I could lay it flat on the TSA inspection conveyor.
The bag comes in several colors; mine is basic black with black interior, and silver waterproof lining on the interior of the cover, and red interior in the laptop section. It is constructed of ballistic nylon, and weighs about 2.5 pounds. The bag measures 15.6" x 11.8" x 5.9" with a laptop section that is 14.4" x 9.4" x 1.6". The bag's bottom is also waterproof.
If you aren't sure if the bag will hold your laptop, please see the Laptop/Tablet Fit Guide at Timbuk2's website.
The shoulder strap is very comfortable and may be removed if you want to use this as a briefcase. It also doubles as an actual messenger strap, handy if you happen to be an actual bike messenger! Me, I just use the bag as a laptop/briefcase, and it's awesome.
The exterior has a top handle, two buckle straps and a pass-through for a luggage handle. It also has an outside compartment for a water bottle, etc. In addition to the buckles, the flap secures with velcro, while the laptop compartment closes with two zippers on the outside, while the padded interior secures with a velcro strap. The bottom of the luggage pass-through also secures with velcro to form a pocket for paperwork on the outside of the laptop compartment. Keep in mind to be TSA compliant, you must have NOTHING but the laptop in this side of the bag!
There are numerous internal compartments. On the laptop side, there is another interior compartment intended for an iPad (or two), which also secures with a velcro strap.
When you lift the flap, you will see several pockets on the front of the main compartment. Back to these in a minute. The bag's main compartment is a good size section, which include a pocket divider, as well as multiple pockets to hold wires, adapters, pens, or anything else you can fit in them. Each is a few inches wide and deep, and a couple have flaps that secure with velcro. There are also a couple of mesh pockets on each end of the compartment interior. For my trip I stored some paperwork, a notebook, boarding passes, several AC adapters, my laptop adapter, two shavers, two point and shoot cameras, some pens, along with my laptop in the laptop compartment and it wasn't not even half full. Now back to the front of the main compartment. This section contains an open pocket where you can fit something the size of your hand. In front of this is a zippered section with a red strap to hold keys. The zippered section is large enough to hold a man's large billfold. There are a couple of other pockets here, each big enough to hold eyeglasses, etc. There are also two areas lined with faux fur. These are very soft and perfect for glasses, or an iPhone. Also in this area is a rectangular pocket which zippers shut. This pocket is accessible even with the bag flap closed, as you can reach in from the side, unzip the compartment and access your items. It even has "vista" loops in case you actually use it as a messenger bag and want to attach bike lights.
This is not an inexpensive bag, but it really is just so well designed and durable, the price is easily justified. I really think this is the best bag I have ever used and I have had some good ones, including some from Targus, Eddie Bauer and a few others. And, oh yeah, it has a lifetime warranty too!
One note and it has nothing to do with the bag's design. Many airports will still make you remove your laptop from a bag even if its fully TSA compliant. I flew roundtrip between Newark and Orlando in July 2012. Newark TSA let me leave the laptop in the bag, but Orlando made me pull it from the bag. Same bag, packed the same way so keep in mind if you buy a TSA compliant bag, you may or may not find you can use it as hoped. That's no reflection on the bag.
So, if you want a really well made bag this should be among your short list.
Read Best Reviews of Timbuk2 Commute TSA-Friendly Messenger Bag Here
This is my first foray into the world of Timbuk2, and I have to say that I am impressed. Yeah, its just a bag, but many of us use bags like these everyday. Having one that is convenient, comfortable, durable, and professional is very important. I am happy to say this bag not only fits all these criteria, but excels in each.
The nylon is extremely tough. I haven't been dragging mine across gravel, but I think that you probably could without doing much damage. It has a nice texture that repels water well. I find I don't have to worry about where I set my bag down because I know the nylon is tough and weatherproof enough to withstand anything I encounter in the course of the day.
The bag is very roomy. I have the medium size, and it is large enough to fit a 15" laptop, an ipad, a couple of large textbooks, a few other miscellaneous items (blood pressure cuff, etc.) and many small odds and ends. If you have a very large 15" laptop with an extended battery that pokes up, it may not fit in the dedicated laptop section and will have to be placed in the main compartment. I haven't seen other sizes, but I would think the medium would be sufficient for most people. It fits comfortably across my shoulder (I am a thin, 6 ft male) and doesn't feel too big across my body.
It has a couple of small zipper pocket, including the napoleon pocket which can be accessed under the flap without undoing the buckle. I like how one of the small zipper pockets has the red timbuk2 key ribbon, so keys can be used and stored without un-clipping them from the bag (for doors, not cars of course). This is great for me, as I have a tendency to misplace my keys.
The shoulder pad that comes with the bag is a little lacking. It's not uncomfortable, but for long periods with my bag I would like some more padding. I have heard that the deluxe shoulder strap pad that timbuk2 sells for $15 is a worthwhile investment. I will order that item and update this review when it comes.
This bag, unlike the Timbuk2 command, does not come with velcro silencers. These can be ordered for $3 directly from Timbuk2. I ordered the silencers so that when I open the flap during class there isn't a loud velcro sound. The velcro and buckles are redundant for closing the flap. This is useful for those who want extra security, but not necessary most of the time.
This bag is quite similar to the command line of bags. the command line has a slightly different look, and has a differently oriented laptop compartment. My friend has the command, and honestly they are similar enough that I don't think you could go wrong with either one. The command has metal hooks to keep the flap closed instead of buckles. This is supposedly quieter (though the buckles are easy to open and close silently), but command's the metal hooks don't stay closed nearly as well and sometimes flap loose. Overall, order either one with confidence.
This bag comes with a lifetime guarantee against manufacturing defects from Timbuk2. From what I've heard, they have great customer support, but I have not yet dealt with them personally.
I haven't found any negatives with this bag yet, but if I do I will update this review.
Want Timbuk2 Commute TSA-Friendly Messenger Bag Discount?
I bought this bag about 1 year ago on sale from Amazon, and I can proudly say that it is one of the best purchases I have ever made. The bag still looks brand new despite the massive amount of punishment I've put it through. It isn't even fraying at the edges.
I've put this bag down in puddles, carried it in storms with my iPad in the laptop sleeve, and taken it on trips. It is definitely TSA approved, no need to take the laptop/tablet out.
PROS:
Sturdy material
Expert construction
Well-thought-out details (such as an extra strip of soft velcro inside the laptop compartment, so that when you open to velcro strap and it falls back down, it doesn't land of the felt lining and fray it)
TONS of pockets that are expertly laid out
Key ribbon. I use this all the time. I'm terrible at keeping track of my keys, so I leave them attached to my bag. It's the perfect length, you can use the keys to unlock doors and the like without any inconvenience.
CONS:
The water bottle holder is not very convenient, as you have to bring the bag to the front to get at it because of the side it is on.
Size. I bought a small, which is generally okay, except I have found myself wishing for more storage on plenty of occasions. I should have just bucked up and got the medium for an extra $15 or so
The strap pad that comes with the bag is a little thin. I had read plenty of other reviews and bought the extra-padded one that Timbuk2 sells and it was worth it. Especially when the bag is completely full.
TL;DR: Lots of great features and sturdy construction make this well worth the price, but get at least a Medium size and buy the extra thick add-on strap pad.
I love this pack. I've taken it on several hikes and two camping trips since I bought it a month ago. It easily carries all the gear I need for summer excursions and I haven't got anywhere near filling its 100 liter capacity. I can't wait until this winter to load it with my four-season equipment and extra clothes.
